At a time when the need for mental and behavioral health care is increasing, Americans of all ages find themselves unable to access such services, with 40 percent of the US population living in a Mental Health Professional Shortage Area. One of the drivers of this care shortage is the lagging supply and capacity of trained behavioral health professionals; indeed, the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) predicts substantial shortages across a large variety of professions within the behavioral health workforce by the 2030s. As such, evidence on policies and strategies to strengthen this critical workforce is sorely needed.
Our research partners are answering that call, launching four new studies that explore a diverse set of questions on how to bolster the behavioral health workforce. From studying the pipeline of family medicine providers of medications for opioid use disorder (MOUD) to exploring how variation in state Medicaid policy impacts service delivery of certified prevention specialists and licensed pastoral counselors, these projects add vital evidence to the ongoing efforts by states, payers, and health systems to address the behavioral health workforce challenges.
Below are the new projects now underway as the UNC Behavioral Health Workforce Research Center (UNC-BHWRC) enters its fifth year of research supported by Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) and the Health Resources and Services Administration:
Regulation and Scope of Practice of Certified Prevention Specialists (CPS) and Licensed and Certified Pastoral Counselors
Given the severity of the behavioral health workforce shortages, experts have begun to consider whether certified prevention specialists (CPS) and licensed pastoral counselors are underutilized in the field and have untapped potential to bolster behavioral health service delivery. Perhaps the non-clinical nature of these roles explains why they have remained overlooked - CPS operate at the systems, policy, and population levels to prevent substance misuse and build protective environments, while certified pastoral counselors integrate faith and spirituality into counseling services.
This study will explore the variations in credentialing, licensure, and scope of practice regulations for these two behavioral health workforces, developing a 50-state database and drawing from licensing boards, administrative codes, and stakeholder interviews. These data will clarify how policy variation across states impacts the ability of CPS and certified pastoral counselors to contribute to the much-needed delivery of behavioral health services. Results from this study may further highlight the potential role that other faith-based counselors could play in addressing the behavioral health workforce shortage and how such credentialing, licensing, and reimbursement policies impact these workforces, as well.
The Self-Pay Behavioral Health Workforce in the United States: Motivations, Tradeoffs, and Decisions About Insurance Participation
A key hurdle in addressing the lack of access to behavioral health care plaguing U.S. patients is the difficulty finding in-network providers and the associated higher cost of seeing out-of-network providers. Recent studies show that out-of-network care was materially higher for behavioral health care than for medical/surgical care and that behavioral health providers that are in-network are reimbursed by insurers substantially less for office visits than medical/surgical providers, likely leading to increasing rates of behavioral health providers operating outside of insurance systems, opting instead for self-pay.
UNC-BHWRC’s study seeks to understand who comprises this self-pay workforce by engaging in qualitative interviews with these providers across ten states. Researchers seek to understand why these providers have opted out of insurance systems and, critically, under what conditions they would consider reengaging with public or private insurance. Such findings will be invaluable for policymakers looking to determine Medicaid participation incentives, loan repayment design, and workforce distribution strategies that appropriately align with clinician outlook and, ultimately, decision-making.
Supervision Models for Peer Support Workers and Their Relationship to Workforce Sustainability: A Scoping Review
Peer support workers have been a rapidly growing segment of the behavioral health workforce over the past ten years, providing a wide array of non-clinical support services and integrating into mental health, substance use, and recovery services. With years of evidence backing the peer support model of care, many state Medicaid programs have incorporated this model into their structure, and most states have developed certification and training requirements for the peer support workforce. However, best practice and supervision requirements for this workforce remain fragmented and vary among states, raising question about workforce stability and continuity.
To better inform Medicaid program design and certification standards that support peer recovery role integrity and workforce sustainability, UNC-BHWRC will undertake a scoping review, synthesizing peer-reviewed and gray literature. Researchers will identify the supervision models used for peer support workers, how they are structured, and which workforce outcomes, such as burnout and retention, are associated with different supervision models. Such a review will provide much-needed evidence to help policymakers understand how to design supervision models for peer support providers to achieve the dual aim of supporting the development of this critical workforce and improving consistency in training and supervision requirements across programs.
From Training to Treatment: Building the Family Medicine MOUD Workforce
While the opioid crisis has been ongoing, with opioids continuing to be a major cause of fatal drug overdoses in the US, policymakers have increasingly considered family physicians to be an untapped avenue for expanding access to care to treat patients with opioid use disorder (OUD), particularly in efforts to increase access to medications for opioid use disorder (MOUD). Despite recent policy changes making it easier for all types of providers to prescribe MOUD, specifically buprenorphine, studies have found that removal of the X-waiver requirement has not led to an acceleration in prescribing buprenorphine. For example, many patients remain unaware that primary care physicians could provide MOUD. With estimates that fewer than 2,500 physicians in the U.S. specialize in addiction medicine and primary care is typically a patient’s first point of contact with the health system, family medicine practices hold untapped potential for improving access to MOUD, particularly in rural areas hit hard by the opioid crisis.
This study seeks to understand potential barriers to building the family medicine MOUD workforce by seeking input from family medicine physicians and program directors via additional MOUD-focused questions in a national survey. Questions will focus on assessing buprenorphine initiation rates, training barriers, and residency program readiness, following the removal of the DEA X-waiver. Researchers posit that these findings will be critical to informing policymakers’ decisions related to faculty development, rural access, and shoring up the pipeline of primary care providers who prescribe MOUD.
AcademyHealth will help disseminate findings from the UNC-BHWRC and promote awareness of the Center's research through its national networks and communication channels. Information about the UNC-BHWRC and previous studies is available here.