2020 was a watershed moment for public health and societal dynamics in the United States. The COVID-19 pandemic, combined with widespread protests against systemic racism, significantly influenced public attitudes on a host of issues. A new study by Schmit et al., published in one of AcademyHealth's partner journals the Milbank Quarterly, delves into how these events shaped privacy preferences and the comfort level of various demographic groups with data use in public health.

Key Findings and Context

Researchers conducted separate online surveys in February and November 2020 to gauge the public's comfort with using identifiable data for public health. These surveys involved 1,373 participants who evaluated different data-use scenarios. Questions focused on three main attributes: the type of data, who used it, and the purpose of its use.

One potentially surprising finding is that the public supported using identifiable data for public health and research purposes, even amid the upheavals of 2020. Notably, bipartisan support did not significantly change between February and November, highlighting a stable consensus on the importance of public health data activities. However, the study also uncovered a unique decline in support among African Americans, a trend not observed in other demographic groups.

The Unique Decline Among African Americans

The decrease in comfort with public health data use among African Americans is particularly concerning. This group exhibited a significant shift in preferences, showing decreased support for using identifiable data for both public health and research. The researchers suggest this may be linked to the heightened awareness of systemic racism and its persistent impacts brought to the forefront by the events of 2020.

African Americans' historical and ongoing experiences with systemic racism and exploitation in research and medical contexts likely contributed to this mistrust as well. The Tuskegee Syphilis Study is a stark example of why such concerns persist. The COVID-19 pandemic further exacerbated these issues, as African American communities faced higher infection and mortality rates, potentially intensifying their skepticism toward data use in public health initiatives.

Broader Implications and Legislative Context

Despite the observed decline in comfort among African Americans, the general public's support for public health data use underscores a critical disconnect between public preferences and legislative action. Current legislative efforts often require more specific provisions for public health data use despite consistent public support for such applications. The study by Schmit et al. reinforces the need for policymakers to align privacy laws with public health necessities.

For instance, the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) protects educational data without exceptions for public health research. Given that education is a significant social determinant of health, excluding such data from public health research hampers our ability to effectively address and understand health disparities. This misalignment between legislative frameworks and public support for health data use highlights the urgent need for legal reforms that facilitate public health research while safeguarding privacy.

Moving Forward: Building Trust and Inclusive Policies

The findings of this study highlight the fragility of public trust, particularly among marginalized communities. Building trust requires transparent, inclusive policies that acknowledge historical injustices and strive to rectify them. Public health officials and researchers must engage with communities to understand their concerns and work collaboratively to ensure that data use benefits all societal groups equitably.

As the United States continues to navigate the complexities of public health in a post-2020 world, this study offers critical insights into how public attitudes have evolved and what steps must be taken to foster a supportive environment for public health data use. By aligning legislative efforts with public preferences and addressing the unique concerns of African Americans, we can create a more inclusive and effective public health landscape. Committing to transparent policies and addressing systemic inequities can build a future where public health initiatives are trusted, inclusive, and, ultimately, more successful.

Aaron Carroll Headshot
Author, Board Member, Member, Staff

Aaron E. Carroll, M.D., M.S.

President and CEO - AcademyHealth

Dr. Aaron E. Carroll is President & CEO of AcademyHealth. A nationally recognized thought leader, science comm... Read Bio

Blog comments are restricted to AcademyHealth members only. To add comments, please sign-in.